Pan Pizza vs Deep Dish: Which One Is Better?

When it comes to pizza, there are few topics more hotly debated than the battle between pan pizza vs deep dish. It’s a classic argument that has been raging for years: does the unique combination of sauce and cheese layered on top of thick crust make deep dish better than its thinner-crusted cousin, the pan pizza? In this blog post, we will dive into this debate by examining both styles of pizza in detail – from their recipes to their histories – so you can decide for yourself which one is ultimately preferred. Get ready to explore the delicious world of Pan vs Deep Dish Pizza!

What Is Pan Pizza?

Pan pizza is a type of pizza made in a deep dish pan and characterized by its thick, chewy crust. It was originally developed in the city of Chicago in 1943 and remains popular today. The dough is usually a combination of all-purpose flour, cornmeal, sugar, oil, salt and water that is pressed into an oiled round or rectangular baking pan. The dough edges are then raised up to form the outer edge of the pizza before it is topped with tomato sauce, cheese (sometimes multiple cheeses), other toppings such as meats, vegetables or fruit and then baked in either a commercial oven or home oven until golden brown.

Pan pizza has become increasingly popular over the years due to its unique flavor profile and hearty texture that stands up well to heavy toppings. It is now a popular dish in both Italian and American-style pizzerias across the country.

What Are The Ingredients In Pan Pizza?

Pan pizza is a classic favorite among many people, and the classic ingredients in pan pizza depend on what type of topping you prefer. Generally, traditional pan pizza consists of cheese, sauce, dough and toppings such as pepperoni or other meats. The dough can be either thick or thin crust depending on your preference. 

Cheese is essential to any good pizza and there are several types that can be used for a pan pizza. Mozzarella cheese is most commonly used, but some recipes call for Cheddar or Parmesan cheese as well for added flavor. 

The sauce is also an important element in pan pizza and traditionally it’s made with tomatoes, garlic and herbs to create the flavorful red sauce people know and love.

Finally, topping your pan pizza is the fun part because you can get creative and choose whatever type of meat or vegetable toppings you like. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and olives are some classic choices that work well with a pan pizza. 

Once all the ingredients are prepared in the right proportions and placed on top of the dough, your pan pizza is ready to go into the oven for baking until it’s golden-brown and bubbly!

How Is Pan Pizza Made?

The process of making a pan pizza is relatively simple. The dough is rolled out and placed in an oiled pan, then topped with sauce and cheese. Additional toppings such as vegetables, meats, or herbs can also be added. Once all the ingredients are added to the pizza, it is baked in the oven until the crust has reached desired crispness. 

After baking, the pizza should be cooled slightly before slicing into pieces for serving. While there are many variations on this classic dish, following these steps will produce a delicious and authentic homemade pan pizza every time! 

What Are Some Pan Pizza Brands?

When it comes to pan pizza, some of the most popular brands include Papa John’s, Domino’s, and Little Caesars. Papa John’s offers a variety of crusts from classic thin and crispy to extra thick. Their toppings range from pepperoni and Italian sausage to mango habanero chicken or banana peppers. Domino’s also has a wide selection of pizzas with both traditional and deep dish crusts. Their signature extrawide slices feature an abundance of cheese and toppings like bacon, ham & pineapple, or salami & mushrooms.

Finally, Little Caesars offers their Detroit-style deep dish square pizza with plenty of pepperoni and cheese on top. They also have options like their Hula Hawaiian Pizza and the 3 Meat Treat. No matter which pan pizza you choose, it’s sure to be delicious!

What Is Deep Dish Pizza?

Deep dish pizza is a type of pizza originating in Chicago, Illinois. It has a thick crust that is similar to a pie shell, with tomato sauce and cheese layered on top. The deep pan creates an incredibly flavorful and delicious pizza experience. Deep dish pizza can often feature other toppings such as vegetables, meats or seafood. It is typically cooked in a high-sided cast iron skillet which helps the dough to stay hot and crisp while baking in the oven.

The result is an intensely flavorful pizza pie that will leave your mouth watering! With its unique cooking method and bold flavor profile, it’s no wonder why deep dish pizza continues to be popular among both locals and visitors alike. If you’re looking for something different from the traditional thin-crust pizza, deep dish is definitely worth a try. You won’t be sorry! 

How Is Deep Dish Pizza Made?

Making deep dish pizza requires more preparation than your typical thin-crust pies. Making the dough and sauce is similar to making any other type of pizza, but layering the ingredients in a deep dish pan gives this classic pie its unique flavor. Here’s how it’s done: 

– Start with the Dough: To make a perfect deep dish crust, you’ll need a thick and hearty dough that can stand up to all of the toppings without losing its shape or structure. The dough should be made with a combination of all-purpose flour, olive oil, yeast, sugar, and salt. When kneading the dough together until it forms a ball shape, take care not to overwork it as this can lead to a tough and dry crust. 

– Pre-Bake the Crust: Once the dough has been kneaded, roll it out into a circle that’s larger than your pan, then place it in the bottom of the pan. The dough should be pressed up against the sides of the pan to create an even layer. Then pre-bake the crust for about 15 minutes at 375°F (190°C). This will help ensure that your pizza comes out with a crispy crust and prevents soggy slices. 

– Add Your Toppings: When layering on toppings for deep dish pizza, start with cheese –– lots of it! A combination of mozzarella and Parmesan is perfect. Then add your favorite toppings such as pepperoni, sausage, vegetables, and herbs. Be sure to spread the toppings evenly so each slice is packed with flavor. 

– Add the Sauce: The final layer should be a hearty tomato sauce that’s seasoned with oregano, garlic powder, and other spices of your choice. This will give the pizza its classic deep dish flavor. 

– Bake It Up: After all of the ingredients have been added to the pan, bake it at 375°F (190°C) for 25-30 minutes or until the crust is golden brown and cheese is melted and bubbly on top. Slice it up and enjoy! 

Making deep dish pizza may take a little extra time, but the end result is always worth it. With its thick and hearty crust and flavorful toppings, this classic pie is sure to be a hit with the whole family. Now that you know how to make deep dish pizza, get cooking!

What Are Some Of The Best Deep Dish Pizzas In The World?

Deep dish pizza is one of the most popular dishes in the world, and it comes with a wide variety of toppings and styles. Many cities have their own signature deep dish style that make them stand out from other places. Here are some of the best deep dish pizzas in the world: 

Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza: This iconic version of pizza hails from Chicago and is characterized by its thick crust, chunky tomato sauce, ample cheese, and piles of toppings. 

New York-Style Deep Dish Pizza: This variation on New York’s classic style features an extra-thick crust loaded up with all kinds of topping options, like pepperoni or sausage. It’s also known for having a crunchy texture. 

Detroit-Style Deep Dish Pizza: Detroit’s version of pizza is thick and crispy with a buttery, flaky crust. It’s often served square instead of round, and it has a caramelized cheese along the edges. 

California-Style Deep Dish Pizza: This deep dish pizza style is characterized by its thin crust, fresh vegetables, and savory sauces. The toppings tend to be lighter than other styles, making it a great option for health-conscious eaters. 

Neapolitan-Style Deep Dish Pizza: This classic Italian style features a thin, yet flavorful crust topped with simple ingredients like tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, oregano, and olive oil. It’s a great option for those looking for a light meal. 

No matter which deep dish pizza style you choose, it’s sure to be delicious! Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or something unique, there is bound to be an option that will satisfy your craving.

What Are Some Of The Best Deep Dish Pizza Recipes?

Deep dish pizza is a classic comfort food that has been around for generations. It’s a favorite among both adults and children alike, and it can be enjoyed with a variety of toppings. But what are some of the best deep dish pizza recipes? Here, we will discuss several options to help you create the perfect homemade deep dish pizza every time. 

The first recipe to consider is a classic Chicago-style deep dish. This version requires using an oiled cast iron skillet to bake your ingredients in layers. Start by rolling out pre-made dough onto the bottom and sides of the skillet then add canned crushed tomatoes as your sauce layer followed by shredded cheese, pepperoni slices, and other desired toppings. Bake this in an oven set at 375°F until the cheese is melted and bubbly.

Alternatively, you can try a deep pan version of your favorite pizza. Start by pre-baking the bottom crust to prevent sogginess then layer in desired ingredients one at a time. This includes sauce, cheese, toppings, and any seasonings or herbs that you would like to add. Bake in an oven set to 425°F for about 20 minutes or until the cheese is golden brown and bubbling.

Finally, you can also make a more traditional Italian-style pizza with this same deep dish method. Begin by preheating your skillet and greasing it lightly before rolling out your dough onto it with some olive oil. Spread on tomato sauce and then layer on fresh mozzarella, oregano, basil, and any other desired toppings. Bake in an oven set to 375°F until the cheese is melted and golden brown.

No matter which variation you choose, deep dish pizza recipes will always be a delicious way to get your comfort food fix. With these three options, you can make a perfectly crispy crust with just the right amount of cheese every time.

Pan Pizza Vs Deep Dish Comparison: Face To Face

When it comes to pan pizza versus deep dish, there is no clear winner as each type of pizza has its own unique flavor and texture. Here are some key differences between the two types of pizza: 

– Pan Pizza typically has a thinner crust and is cooked in a shallow baking pan, while Deep Dish pizzas have a thicker crust and are usually baked in a deep-dish pan. 

– The toppings for both types of pizza can vary greatly, but generally speaking you will find more toppings on Deep Dish than on Pan Pizzas. 

– The cooking time also differs between the two types of pizza; Deep Dish requires more time to cook due to its thicker crust and heavier toppings. 

– The taste and texture of the two types of pizza can also vary, with Pan Pizza often having a crisper crust and a lighter, more airy texture than Deep Dish pizza. 

– Finally, the cost difference between the two types of pizza is typically quite significant; Deep Dish pizzas tend to be more expensive due to their thicker crusts and heavier toppings. 

At the end of it all, it comes down to personal preference as both types of pizza have their own unique flavor and textures that are sure to please any pizza lover! With so many variables like crust, topping selection, cooking time, taste, and price, you’ll have no problem finding the perfect type of pizza for your next meal. So, enjoy exploring the world of pizza!

>>> You might also like:

Pizza Hut Pan pizza vs Hand Tossed

How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge

How Many Calories In A Slice Of Pizza?

FAQs About Pan Pizza Vs Deep Dish

Pan pizza and deep-dish pizza are two popular types of pizzas. But there are some differences between them. Here is a list of frequently asked questions about the two types of pizza: 

What Ingredients Make Up Pan Pizza? 

Pan pizzas typically use a thicker crust than other types of pizza, as well as ingredients such as mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, and various toppings like vegetables or meats.

How Is Deep Dish Different From Pan Pizza? 

Deep-dish pizzas have a much thicker crust that has more dough in it, creating an edge around the entire circumference of the pie. They also typically contain more cheese and other toppings compared to pan pizzas.

What Kind Of Pan Is Used For A Pan Pizza? 

Typically, a round or rectangular baking dish is used to cook pan pizzas. The sides of the pan should be at least an inch high in order to create the right texture and crunch when cooked.

Does Deep-Dish Pizza Take Longer To Cook Than Pan Pizza? 

Yes, deep-dish pizza can take anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour to cook due to its thicker crust and additional toppings compared to other types of pizza. Pan pizzas usually only take around 10-15 minutes to bake depending on your oven temperature. 

Is One Type Healthier Than The Other? 

It depends on the ingredients and toppings used in each type of pizza. However, generally speaking, deep-dish pizza tends to be higher in calories due to its thicker crust and additional cheese and toppings. 

>>> See more: The Secret Behind Chicago Deep Dish Pizza


In the end, the decision between Pan Pizza Vs Deep Dish comes down to personal opinion. While pizzerias like Giordano’s swear by deep dish as the most delicious style of pizza, others prefer a more traditional option like pan pizza. To decide for yourself, why not give both styles a try? Giordano’s offers an online ordering service so you can easily compare the two and pick your favorite without ever leaving the comfort of your home.

You may have been on the fence before, but now you know that with pan pizza or deep dish you can’t go wrong! So why not ask yourself: “Pan Pizza Vs Deep Dish- which one is better?” And find out what works best for you.

The Village Pizza Nags Head is a local favorite for fresh, handmade pizza and Italian cuisine. Our blog features recipes, specials, and more!