Old World Pepperoni vs Regular Pepperoni: Which One is Better?

When it comes to pizzas, the topping that always seems to come to mind is pepperoni. A crowd favorite due to its smoky flavor and sizzle when baked in the oven, pepperoni has become one of the most popular pizza toppings across America. But there are two types of pepperonis available: old world style and regular style. While both offer their own unique taste profiles, how do you decide which one is right for your next pizza night?

Old world pepperoni vs regular pepperoni: In this blog post, we’ll explore the differences between old world-style pepperoni and regular pepperoni – from texture & appearance to flavors & uses – so you can make an informed decision about which will be more suitable for your needs!

What Is Regular Pepperoni?

Regular pepperoni is a type of salami that is usually made from cured pork and beef mixed together. It has a medium to high fat content, which gives it its characteristic flavor. It is typically seasoned with paprika, garlic, fennel, sugar, anise and other spices. As the name suggests, regular pepperoni has a traditional red-orange color and comes in slices or discs. It can be used as a topping on pizzas or sandwiches as well as an ingredient for pasta and noodle dishes.

This type of pepperoni keeps for weeks when properly stored in the refrigerator. Regular pepperoni also makes an excellent addition to charcuterie boards or cheese platters. When grated into small pieces it can provide both texture and flavor to salads, omelets and other dishes.  The list of recipes that can be enhanced with regular pepperoni is almost endless. Discover new ways to add this versatile ingredient to your favorite dishes!

How Is Regular Pepperoni Made?

Regular pepperoni is a type of sausage that is typically made from a mixture of beef and pork. The process of making regular pepperoni involves several steps:

– Meat selection: The first step in making regular pepperoni is selecting the type of meat that will be used. Typically, a combination of beef and pork is used, as this provides a good balance of flavors and textures.

– Grinding and mixing: The meat is then ground and mixed together with various spices and seasonings, such as paprika, garlic, fennel, and red pepper flakes. These ingredients give the pepperoni its distinctive flavor and color.

– Curing and drying: After the meat is mixed with the spices, it is then cured with salt and nitrates to help preserve it and prevent spoilage. The cured meat is then dried and fermented for several days, during which time it develops its characteristic tangy flavor.

– Slicing: Once the pepperoni is fully dried, it is sliced into thin, circular pieces that are typically about 1/8 inch thick.

Regular pepperoni can be used as a topping on pizzas, sandwiches, and other dishes, and is known for its slightly spicy and savory flavor.

What Is Old World Pepperoni?

Old World Pepperoni is a type of cured Italian sausage typically made with pork, paprika, salt, and black pepper. It can also contain garlic, fennel seed, anise seed, sugar, and other spices. The list of ingredients varies depending on the recipe used. This sausage is distinctively spicier than traditional American pepperoni and often contains more herbs and seasonings. It has a deep red color from the high amount of paprika found within it.

Old World Pepperoni can be served part of an antipasto platter or added to pizzas for extra flavor. It is also commonly sliced into thin rings for snacking or topping salads. However you choose to enjoy it, Old World Pepperoni will bring a flavorful and exciting addition to your dishes. 

Old World Pepperoni is a great way to add more flavor and spice to any dish that calls for sausage. With its unique blend of spices, it can turn an ordinary meal into something extraordinary. Whether you are serving up classic Italian family favorites or creating something new, Old World Pepperoni will surely make your taste buds happy. Try adding this spicy sausage to pizzas, sandwiches, salads and more for an added kick! You won’t regret it! 

The possibilities are endless when it comes to cooking with Old World Pepperoni. Its unique taste and texture adds depth to many recipes from soups and stews all the way through main entrees like pasta dishes and pizza.

What Is The Origin Of Old World Pepperoni?

Old World pepperoni is a type of cured meat that originated in Italy. The name “pepperoni” actually comes from the Italian word “peperoni,” which means bell peppers, and not from the meat itself. In Italy, pepperoni sausage is typically made with a combination of beef and pork, and is flavored with paprika and chili peppers. This type of pepperoni is often used as a pizza topping in Italy and other parts of Europe.

In the United States, however, pepperoni has evolved to refer specifically to a type of spicy, dry sausage made primarily from beef and pork, and flavored with a variety of spices including paprika, chili powder, and fennel seeds. Old World pepperoni is a variation of this type of pepperoni that is made using traditional Italian methods, with a coarser grind and a more intense, spicy flavor than the milder American-style pepperoni.

How Is Old World Pepperoni Made?

Old World pepperoni is a type of pepperoni that is made using a traditional Italian method. The process of making Old World pepperoni is similar to that of regular pepperoni, but there are a few key differences:

– Meat selection: Old World pepperoni is typically made with pork only, whereas regular pepperoni is made with a combination of beef and pork.

– Grinding and mixing: The meat is ground and mixed with spices and seasonings, such as paprika, fennel, anise, and cayenne pepper. The mixture is then stuffed into casings and fermented for several days.

– Drying and aging: After fermentation, the pepperoni is hung to dry and age for several weeks. This process allows the flavors to develop and intensify, resulting in a more complex and robust flavor than regular pepperoni.

– Slicing: Once the aging process is complete, the pepperoni is sliced into thin rounds and can be used as a topping for pizzas and other dishes.

Old World pepperoni is known for its slightly smoky and tangy flavor, as well as its distinctive chewy texture. It is often used in traditional Italian-style pizzas, as well as in sandwiches and appetizers.

Old World Pepperoni vs Regular Pepperoni Comparison: Face To Face

When it comes to comparing Old World pepperoni and regular pepperoni, there are several key differences to consider.

– Ingredients: Old World pepperoni is typically made with pork only, while regular pepperoni is made with a combination of beef and pork. This difference in meat selection can affect the flavor and texture of the pepperoni.

– Seasonings: Old World pepperoni is seasoned with traditional Italian spices, such as paprika, fennel, and anise, which give it a slightly smoky and tangy flavor. Regular pepperoni, on the other hand, may have a more generic spice blend.

– Fermentation: Old World pepperoni is fermented for several days before it is dried and aged, which allows the flavors to develop and intensify. Regular pepperoni may not go through this fermentation process.

– Texture: Old World pepperoni has a chewy texture, while regular pepperoni can be slightly crispy and greasy.

– Use: Old World pepperoni is often used in traditional Italian-style pizzas and dishes, while regular pepperoni is more commonly used on American-style pizzas.

In summary, Old World pepperoni is a more traditional, artisanal product that is made with high-quality ingredients and a careful attention to detail. Regular pepperoni, on the other hand, is a more generic product that is widely available and used in a variety of dishes. The choice between the two will ultimately depend on personal preference and the desired flavor and texture profile.

How To Choose Between Old World Pepperoni And Regular Pepperoni?

Choosing between Old World pepperoni and regular pepperoni ultimately comes down to personal preference.

If you prefer a milder, slightly sweeter flavor with a softer texture, regular pepperoni may be your best choice. It’s typically made with a blend of pork and beef, and often contains less fat than Old World pepperoni.

On the other hand, if you enjoy a spicier, more robust flavor with a firmer texture, Old World pepperoni may be more to your liking. It’s usually made with 100% pork and is often aged for a longer period of time to develop its distinct flavor.

Consider experimenting with both types of pepperoni to see which one you prefer on your pizza. Some pizza shops and restaurants may offer both options, so don’t be afraid to ask if you’re curious.

>>> You might also like:

Size Matters: 12 Inch vs 16 Inch Pizza

Comparing 10 Inch vs 12 Inch Pizzas

12 vs 14 Inch Pizza: Choosing Your Perfect Pizza

Is Old World Pepperoni Healthier Than Regular Pepperoni?

There isn’t a clear answer to whether Old World pepperoni is healthier than regular pepperoni, as it depends on the specific ingredients and nutritional values of each brand or product.

In general, Old World pepperoni is often made with 100% pork, which can make it higher in fat and calories than regular pepperoni made with a blend of pork and beef. Additionally, Old World pepperoni is usually aged for a longer period of time to develop its distinct flavor, which can also impact its nutritional value.

However, it’s important to note that the nutritional values can vary greatly between brands and products, so it’s always best to check the nutrition labels and ingredient lists to make an informed decision. As with any food, moderation is key, and enjoying either type of pepperoni as part of a balanced diet is the best approach for overall health.

Can I Use Old World Pepperoni In A Regular Pepperoni Pizza Recipe?

Yes, you can use Old World pepperoni in a regular pepperoni pizza recipe. However, keep in mind that Old World pepperoni has a different texture and flavor profile than regular pepperoni, so it may change the overall taste of the pizza. Additionally, Old World pepperoni tends to be spicier than regular pepperoni, so you may need to adjust the amount of pepperoni you use depending on your personal preference.

How Should I Store Old World Pepperoni Vs Regular Pepperoni?

Both Old World pepperoni and regular pepperoni should be stored in the refrigerator. Once opened, they should be wrapped tightly in plastic wrap or placed in an airtight container to keep them from drying out. It’s important to consume them before their expiration date for optimal freshness and taste.

If you have a large quantity of pepperoni that you won’t be using in the near future, you can also freeze it for longer-term storage. To freeze pepperoni, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and then place it in a freezer-safe bag. It can be stored in the freezer for up to 6 months. When you’re ready to use it, thaw it in the refrigerator before using it on your pizza or other dishes.

What Are The Benefits Of Old World Pepperoni Vs Regular Pepperoni?

Old World pepperoni and regular pepperoni have different characteristics and benefits. Here are some potential benefits of each:

Benefits of Old World Pepperoni:

Authentic flavor: Old World pepperoni is made using traditional Italian methods, resulting in a distinct, bold flavor.

Higher quality ingredients: Old World pepperoni is often made with high-quality pork and natural spices, which can be healthier than the additives and preservatives found in some regular pepperoni.

Artisanal production: Old World pepperoni is usually produced in small batches and aged to perfection, giving it a unique texture and complexity.

Lower fat content: Some varieties of Old World pepperoni have a lower fat content compared to regular pepperoni, which may make them a healthier option.

Benefits of Regular Pepperoni:

Widespread availability: Regular pepperoni is a common pizza topping and can be found at most pizzerias and grocery stores.

Consistent flavor: Regular pepperoni has a consistent taste and texture, making it a reliable option for pizza lovers.

Affordable: Regular pepperoni is often less expensive than artisanal varieties, making it a budget-friendly option.

Ultimately, the choice between Old World pepperoni and regular pepperoni depends on personal preference and dietary needs.

>>> See more: Little Caesars NEW Old World Fanceroni Pizza Review!

Conclusion: After taking a closer look at Old World Pepperoni and Regular Pepperoni we can see the differences in flavor, texture and origin. Old World Pepperoni packs more of a punch with robust flavors of fennel and garlic that produce a unique aroma. Regular Pepperoni often has a milder flavor due to its combination of beef, pork, paprika and other spices.  The texture also differs as Old World Pepperoni is drier than regular pepperoni as it is cured just like Italian salami.

Finally, Old World Pepperoni originated in Italy where it is still very popular today, while regular pepperoni was modernized in the USA. Whether you are looking for an intensely flavorful snack or something with a milder taste, be sure to try out both types of pepperonis to decide which one you prefer. Try out Old World Pepperoni vs Regular Pepperoni to find out your favorite!

This blog is all about Village Pizza in Nags Head, NC. We’ll post about specials, new menu items, and anything else happening at the restaurant.